A Must Read Alert

I wish I had written this. The Big Push for Midwives has once again done great work in educating us in what goes on behind the scenes. Thanks to PushGirl Friday for her insight at:

Please read her blog.....
A Tale of Two MOMS: ACOG Pulls a Fast One on Groundbreaking Maternity Care Legislation

As many readers here know, last summer Congresswoman Lucille Roybal-Allard introduced the MOMS (Maximizing Optimal Maternity Services) for the 21st Century Act, a groundbreaking piece of legislation that has the potential to revolutionize our maternity care system. The bill makes increasing access to evidence-based care, reducing racial and ethnic disparities in birth outcomes, and bringing down maternity care costs national priorities by promoting a number of common-sense, low-cost solutions to addressing the maternity care crisis in the US, such as:

Creating loan repayment programs to increase the numbers of family practice physicians, nurse-midwives, and certified professional midwives, all of whom provide low-cost, high-satisfaction alternatives to traditional obstetrical care
Increasing access to culturally competent care and reducing disparities by taking measures to recruit more racially and ethnically diverse students into the maternity care workforce
Launching a public awareness campaign to inform women of the benefits of increasing access to evidence-based maternity care and reducing over-reliance on often unnecessary interventions, such as labor induction, electronic fetal monitoring, episiotomy, and cesarean section
Establishing an Interagency Coordinating Committee on the Promotion of Optimal Maternity Outcomes
The MOMS Act has attracted a broad-based coalition of advocacy and professional organizations, including Amnesty International, Childbirth Connection, The Big Push for Midwives Campaign, the American College of Nurse-Midwives, the National Association of Certified Professional Midwives, the American Association of Birth Centers, and the Midwives Alliance of North America, all of whom have been working together with Representative Roybal-Allard’s office to build support for the bill both within Congress and among the general public.

Notably absent from the list of MOMS Act supporters is the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, which is already busy lobbying Congress about its own forthcoming legislation. Not to be confused with the MOMS Act, ACOG’S proposed Making Obstetrics and Maternity Safer bill, which in the interests of clarity has been dubbed—wait for it—the MOMS Initiative, will, as ACOG President Dr. Richard Waldman stated, “lead the way” in making maternity care safer by promoting research into the causes of premature birth, obesity, and racial disparities in outcomes. Because as we all know, the problem with maternity care in the US is with the women who receive it, not with the care they receive.

Perhaps a better title for ACOG’s MOMS legislation would be the Making Obstetricians More Satisfied Initiative, because the proposal contains absolutely no provisions that encourage obstetricians to abandon current practices in favor of evidence-based care or to give up an inch of turf in their ongoing battle to protect their virtual monopoly on the maternity care market in the US—a monopoly that is responsible for creating the need for the Real MOMS Act in the first place. ACOG laid the groundwork for its sabotage of the bill in a recent letter that has been circulating in DC, assuring Congress that the organization has already put many patient safety measures into place and that their own MOMS legislation “can lead to direct measurable improvements in patient safety and quality of care, and to healthier births.” No promises that the Misleading MOMS Act actually will lead to improvements, but hey—it’s a start, right?

As for the Real MOMS Act? According to Dr. Waldman it is unacceptable because a) it promotes “the wholesale adoption of delivery models that have not yet been proven safe and effective, including doula support, group prenatal care, and home-birth,” and b) it “questions ob-gyns’ ability, compared to certified nurse-midwives, family physicians, and certified professional midwives, to deliver care that supports physiologic birth.” In other words, the Real MOMS Act told the Emperor he has no clothes, he took offense, and now he’s busy knitting himself a new Naked Suit.

Watch this blog for further developments on the Real and Fake MOMS legislative front as we head into a new Congressional session in January. In the meantime, please spread the word about Congresswoman Roybal-Allard’s brave stance in support of real maternity care reform. We need more champions like her who are willing to speak up on behalf mothers and babies and who won’t be fooled by ACOG’s bait-and-switch tactics.

As one who has seen pregnancy from both sides of this "debate" my wish is that ACOG and academic medicine would stop maligning evidenced based midwifery as in doing so they only malign themselves. There is a role for collaboration between the models but it is time for ACOG to realize that more medical intervention may not be the solution to the rising intervention rates. Nurturing care, individual attention and prevention do work and have been the way of the midwife for centuries. Dr F