The reasoning for this position seems to be a circuitous argument against choice. They selectively quote ACOG recommendations for breeches (Committee Opinion #340) to be performed "under hospital-specific protocol guidelines for both eligibility and labor management". Yet they have no protocols or guidelines so therefore elective breech deliveries cannot be performed. Also, they do not seem to be in any hurry to write them. It has been suggested that I work with the OB department to develop such guidelines. I have written a set of simple guidelines for this most natural of processes. I have extended an offer in writing, both in the past and presently, to contribute to the process but have yet to have any invitation from the OB committee. Meanwhile, patients have to wait in limbo.
Finally, in the context of the breech discussion, the hospital administration states that their facilities are not suited for procedures that challenge established professional norms. Once again, clarifying their position that a patient's choice of a breech delivery is outside the norm for a trained, skilled practitioner. Those of us that perform breech deliveries and keep up on the current literature and evidence know that there is nothing special about this "procedure". Breech labors progress or don't like any other labors. They succeed or stall like any other vertex labor. On occasion they require urgent intervention like any other labor. They do not require any special staffing or equipment. Any unit that can do vertex deliveries, high risk obstetrics and elective c/sections can surely handle the laboring woman with a frank or complete breech.
I must respect their position even though I disagree with it. Hospital's have the right to make choices for whatever reason and to have those choices honored. I just wish they felt the same about the patients they profess to serve. In my opinion, they are missing out on a great marketing opportunity. I have expressed this to the CEO but his options are limited as he defers medical decisions to the OB committee. So, what to do? Well, they say, "If you can't beat them, join them." However, what if joining them is out of the question because it compromises your values? My hope is to compete with them. To provide another model to deliver obstetric care in a facility that is midwifery model and patient friendly. This is what I am working on and will keep you posted. Have a good week. SJF